The Federal Trade Commission has given its first hint of how it intends to enforce the new endorsement guidelines that apply to bloggers, by revealing it investigated retailer AnnTaylor for a promotion run by its LOFT brand stores.
In January, AnnTaylor invited a group of bloggers to a preview event for LOFT’s Summer 2010 collection. The invitation stated that bloggers who wrote about the event and submitted their stories to AnnTaylor within 24 hours of the event would receive a mystery gift card worth between $50 and $500.
The blogger promotion was widely reported on in media as an obvious violation of the new FTC endorsement guidelines, and not surprisingly, drew the attention of FTC investigators. The FTC has widely been expected to find a company to use as an example to test the new guidelines on.
On April 20th, the FTC notified AnnTaylor that they have decided not to pursue enforcement action over the event for several reasons:
- A sign was displayed telling bloggers to disclose the gift cards.
- AnnTaylor adopted a new policy shortly afterward requiring notification of bloggers requiring their disclosure requirements before gifts are issued.
- The event was a flop – only a small number of bloggers wrote content, and several who did disclosed the gift cards.
- AnnTaylor only hosted one such event.
This may be good news for advertisers. It appears that the FTC may not hold advertisers accountable for a blogger’s failure to disclose as long as the blogger was notified of their need to disclose.
Another clue to the FTC’s thinking on enforcement was provided by an interview that Cleland gave in January to Jeff Bercovici of Daily Finance. In the interview, he suggested that celebrities would be exempt from disclosures because:
The average consumer, Cleland said, might well be aware that celebrities of Paltrow’s stature often receive free clothing, trips and other swag.
The question, of course, is how this applies in a niche market like scrapbooking – does the FTC recognize the existence of “niche market” celebrities who would fall under Cleland’s interpretation? And if they do, how many people in the industry would fall into that category in their eyes?
Many in the scrapbook industry will be watching for the FTC’s future interpretation of these guidelines, due to the widespread use of editorial and designer samples in the industry, and the prevalence of online publishing of materials.